按键盘上方向键 ← 或 → 可快速上下翻页，按键盘上的 Enter 键可回到本书目录页，按键盘上方向键 ↑ 可回到本页顶部！
————未阅读完？加入书签已便下次继续阅读！
the ontological argument… to which it serves merely as an
introduction； and that； consequently； this argument contains the
only possible ground of proof （possessed by speculative reason） for
the existence of this being。
The chief momenta in the physico…theological argument are as follow：
1。 We observe in the world manifest signs of an arrangement full of
purpose； executed with great wisdom； and argument in whole of a
content indescribably various； and of an extent without limits。 2。
This arrangement of means and ends is entirely foreign to the things
existing in the world… it belongs to them merely as a contingent
attribute； in other words； the nature of different things could not of
itself； whatever means were employed； harmoniously tend towards
certain purposes； were they not chosen and directed for these purposes
by a rational and disposing principle； in accordance with certain
fundamental ideas。 3。 There exists； therefore； a sublime and wise
cause （or several）； which is not merely a blind； all…powerful
nature； producing the beings and events which fill the world in
unconscious fecundity； but a free and intelligent cause of the
world。 4。 The unity of this cause may be inferred from the unity of
the reciprocal relation existing between the parts of the world； as
portions of an artistic edifice… an inference which all our
observation favours； and all principles of analogy support。
In the above argument； it is inferred from the analogy of certain
products of nature with those of human art； when it pels Nature
to bend herself to its purposes； as in the case of a house； a ship； or
a watch； that the same kind of causality… namely； understanding and
will… resides in nature。 It is also declared that the internal
possibility of this freely…acting nature （which is the source of all
art； and perhaps also of human reason） is derivable from another and
superhuman art… a conclusion which would perhaps be found incapable of
standing the test of subtle transcendental criticism。 But to neither
of these opinions shall we at present object。 We shall only remark
that it must be confessed that； if we are to discuss the subject of
cause at all； we cannot proceed more securely than with the guidance
of the analogy subsisting between nature and such products of
design… these being the only products whose causes and modes of
organization are pletely known to us。 Reason would be unable to
satisfy her own requirements； if she passed from a causality which she
does know； to obscure and indemonstrable principles of explanation
which she does not know。
According to the physico…theological argument； the connection and
harmony existing in the world evidence the contingency of the form
merely； but not of the matter； that is； of the substance of the world。
To establish the truth of the latter opinion； it would be necessary to
prove that all things would be in themselves incapable of this harmony
and order； unless they were； even as regards their substance； the
product of a supreme wisdom。 But this would require very different
grounds of proof from those presented by the analogy with human art。
This proof can at most； therefore； demonstrate the existence of an
architect of the world； whose efforts are limited by the
capabilities of the material with which he works； but not of a creator
of the world； to whom all things are subject。 Thus this argument is
utterly insufficient for the task before us… a demonstration of the
existence of an all…sufficient being。 If we wish to prove the
contingency of matter； we must have recourse to a transcendental
argument； which the physicotheological was constructed expressly to
avoid。
We infer； from the order and design visible in the universe； as a
disposition of a thoroughly contingent character； the existence of a
cause proportionate thereto。 The conception of this cause must contain
certain determinate qualities； and it must therefore be regarded as
the conception of a being which possesses all power； wisdom； and so
on； in one word； all perfection… the conception； that is； of an
all…sufficient being。 For the predicates of very great； astonishing；
or immeasurable power and excellence； give us no determinate
conception of the thing； nor do they inform us what the thing may be
in itself。 They merely indicate the relation existing between the
magnitude of the object and the observer； who pares it with himself
and with his own power of prehension； and are mere expressions of
praise and reverence； by which the object is either magnified； or
the observing subject depreciated in relation to the object。 Where
we have to do with the magnitude （of the perfection） of a thing； we
can discover no determinate conception； except that which
prehends all possible perfection or pleteness； and it is only
the total （omnitudo） of reality which is pletely determined in
and through its conception alone。
Now it cannot be expected that any one will be bold enough to
declare that he has a perfect insight into the relation which the
magnitude of the world he contemplates bears （in its extent as well as
in its content） to omnipotence； into that of the order and design in
the world to the highest wisdom； and that of the unity of the world to
the absolute unity of a Supreme Being。 Physico…theology is therefore
incapable of presenting a determinate conception of a supreme cause of
the world； and is therefore insufficient as a principle of theology… a
theology which is itself to be the basis of religion。
The attainment of absolute totality is pletely impossible on
the path of empiricism。 And yet this is the path pursued in the
physicotheological argument。 What means shall we employ to bridge
the abyss？
After elevating ourselves to admiration of the magnitude of the
power； wisdom； and other attributes of the author of the world； and
finding we can advance no further； we leave the argument on
empirical grounds； and proceed to infer the contingency of the world
from the order and conformity to aims that are observable in it。
From this contingency we infer； by the help of transcendental
conceptions alone； the existence of something absolutely necessary；
and； still advancing； proceed from the conception of the absolute
necessity of the first cause to the pletely determined or
determining conception thereof… the conception of an all…embracing
reality。 Thus the physico…theological； failing in its undertaking；
recurs in its embarrassment to the cosmological argument； and； as this
is merely the ontological argument in disguise； it executes its design
solely by the aid of pure reason； although it at first professed to
have no connection with this faculty and to base its entire
procedure upon experience alone。
The physico…theologians have therefore no reason to regard with such
contempt the transcendental mode of argument； and to look down upon
it； with the conceit of clear…sighted observers of nature； as the
brain…cobweb of obscure speculatists。 For； if they reflect upon and
examine their own arguments； they will find that； after following
for some time the path of nature and experience； and discovering
themselves no nearer their object； they